The rise of AI tools like Overviews and AI Mode is causing a sharp decline in organic traffic for major news publishers. Additionally, media outlets like The Atlantic, The Washington Post, and HuffPost have been severely impacted. The tools reduce click-throughs by giving users direct answers. Meanwhile, Google insists that its AI innovations continue to generate billions of clicks. It is now necessary for outlets to adjust to the rapidly changing digital media landscape.
How AI Tools Triggered a Traffic Crisis?
The CEOs of The Atlantic’s Nicholas Thompson, and The Post’s William Lewis, are cautioning about Google’s transition from a search engine to an “answer engine.” They think that the future of journalism is seriously threatened by this shift.
Business Insider’s search-based visits fell by 55% from April 2022 to April 2025. The Washington Post saw a nearly equal decline in visits, and HuffPost saw a loss of over half. Therefore, news publishers need to reconsider how they attract audiences outside of search engines as user habits change.
Can News Publishers Survive the Google Shift?
Executives are raising concerns. The Atlantic’s Nicholas Thompson advised employees to prepare for the possibility that Google traffic may eventually reach zero. Additionally, his publication is reconsidering its whole content strategy. “Google is shifting from a search engine to an answer engine,” he told the Wall Street Journal.
The CEO of The Washington Post, William Lewis, echoed that urgency. He referred to AI-powered summaries as “a serious threat to journalism.” The Post is working to engage untapped audiences and explore new revenue sources.
Even the New York Times faces challenges. Its organic search traffic dropped from 44% in 2022 to 36.5% in April 2025. However, the paper is retaliating by collaborating with Amazon to license training materials for AI. While some see this as a lifeline, others fear it’s a temporary fix for a larger disruption in how readers discover content.
Google Defends AI Despite Publisher Backlash
According to Google, the web ecosystem still benefits from its AI tools. These features “enhance search” and generate billions of clicks every day, according to a company spokesperson. Additionally, Google claims that it keeps users informed and involved by enabling richer, faster results.
However, critics claim that these AI products frequently plagiarize news publishers’ content without credit or compensation. This is particularly problematic when tools are trained to provide answers based on pre-existing articles without ever directing users to the source.
In response, some news outlets are trying to reach licensing agreements with tech firms. Others are focusing on newsletters, branded content, and subscriptions. Relying only on organic traffic is no longer a viable strategy in this “post-search” future.
Can Journalism Adapt to AI Tools?
A significant change is ahead for the digital news sector. Search engine-based business models are becoming unreliable as AI tools continue to change how people obtain information. As a result, news publishers must act quickly to adapt. The key to survival is moving beyond organic traffic alone, whether that is accomplished through partnerships, paywalls, or innovation.
Today, newsrooms need to emphasize data-driven engagement and direct reader relationships. Additionally, content strategies must prioritize brand trust and originality over search optimization alone. The industry could lose its financial stability and influence if bold innovation isn’t implemented.
About The Author
